How Small Businesses Can Qualify for Cyber Insurance in 2025

Cyber insurance used to be simple: fill out a short form, pay a reasonable premium, and rest easy knowing you were covered.

But in 2025? It’s a different story.

Insurance providers have been flooded with claims from ransomware, phishing, and data breaches—and they’re fighting back with stricter requirements, higher premiums, and more exclusions.

If your small business is applying for cyber insurance—or trying to renew your policy—you’ve likely already run into this. And if you’re not prepared, you may be denied coverage entirely.

Let’s break down what’s changed, why it matters, and how NextGEN IT Solutions helps businesses like yours qualify for coverage, reduce premiums, and stay protected.

---

Why Cyber Insurance Is So Tough Now

The cyber insurance industry took a massive hit over the past few years:

• Ransomware payouts skyrocketed, with many small businesses unable to recover on their own
• Insurers paid out more in claims than they collected in premiums
• Cybercriminals targeted insured businesses, knowing insurers would pressure them to pay
• Regulators began demanding more accountability from insurers and policyholders alike

The result? Tighter underwriting standards.

---

What Insurers Want to See Now

To even qualify for coverage—or to avoid sky-high premiums—you’ll need to demonstrate that you have the following in place:

✅ Endpoint Detection & Response (EDR)
✅ Multifactor Authentication (MFA)
✅ Encrypted, tested backups
✅ Regular patch management
✅ Phishing training and simulations
✅ Documented incident response plan
✅ Privileged access controls
✅ 24/7 monitoring
✅ Vendor risk management
✅ Email filtering and DNS protection

And they won’t just take your word for it. Most insurers now require proof.

---

Real Story: Denied Coverage for Lack of MFA

A professional services firm in Cranberry Township was shocked to receive a denial on their cyber insurance renewal.

Why? Their Microsoft 365 accounts didn’t have MFA enabled, and they couldn’t show evidence of endpoint protection on all devices.

We stepped in, implemented both within a week, provided audit logs, and worked directly with the insurer to help them reapply—and get approved.

---

Why This Matters for Small Businesses

You may think your business is too small to be a target—but that’s exactly what cybercriminals are counting on.

And without insurance, you’re exposed to:

• Ransomware recovery costs
• Legal fees and breach notification expenses
• Client lawsuits or contract penalties
• Data recovery and downtime losses
• Compliance violations and fines

Cyber insurance won’t prevent an attack—but it can help you survive one. If you can qualify.

---

How NextGEN IT Solutions Helps You Get Covered

We specialize in helping small and midsize businesses across Western Pennsylvania meet—and prove—cyber insurance requirements.

Here’s how we do it:

---

1. Cyber Insurance Readiness Assessment

We start by reviewing your environment, policies, and tools against the most common insurer questionnaires.

You’ll get a clear report showing:

• What’s already in place
• What’s missing
• What you’ll need to do to get covered
• How to present your environment for approval

This saves time—and gives you leverage when negotiating rates.

---

2. Deploying the Right Security Controls

We implement or manage everything insurers want to see, including:

• EDR: We deploy advanced endpoint protection with rollback, isolation, and threat hunting
• MFA: Enabled across Microsoft 365, remote access, and internal apps
• Backups: Encrypted, off-site, and tested monthly
• Patching: Automated for OS and third-party software
• Email filtering: Blocks spam, malware, and phishing attempts
• DNS filtering: Prevents access to malicious domains
• Admin controls: Limits privileged access and tracks all changes

All backed by documentation for your insurer.

---

3. Compliance and Documentation

We help you prepare:

• Written information security policies
• Acceptable use and remote access policies
• Incident response plans
• Business continuity plans
• User security training logs
• Access control documentation
• Vendor management documentation

Need help filling out your cyber insurance questionnaire? We’ll walk you through it—or complete it for you.

---

4. vCISO Services for Strategic Planning

Need help negotiating with insurers or meeting evolving standards?

Our virtual Chief Information Security Officer (vCISO) services include:

• Strategic guidance on risk posture
• Cyber insurance renewal support
• Board-level reporting and presentations
• Compliance alignment (HIPAA, GLBA, FTC, etc.)

---

Already Have Insurance? Use It to Lower Your Premium

When you work with us, we’ll help you submit documentation that demonstrates:

• Active monitoring
• Incident prevention controls
• Low risk profile
• Prompt response capability
• Staff training programs

Insurers love low-risk clients—and we help you prove that’s you.

---

Don’t Wait for Your Renewal to Be Denied

If your cyber insurance is up for renewal soon, start preparing now. Most insurers will begin assessments 90–120 days before renewal.

Already denied? We can help you reapply after improving your environment.

---

Who Needs This the Most?

We recommend cyber insurance support for any business that:

• Is applying for cyber insurance for the first time
• Recently had a premium increase or coverage denial
• Handles sensitive client, patient, or financial data
• Uses cloud apps like Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace
• Works with third-party vendors or contractors
• Wants to comply with HIPAA, GLBA, or FTC Safeguards

---

Why Work with NextGEN IT Solutions?

We’re a Pennsylvania-based MSP with over 26 years of experience helping small businesses build secure, compliant, insurable environments.

We’ve helped clients in Grove City, Pittsburgh, Slippery Rock, and Erie:

• Qualify for cyber insurance
• Reduce premiums
• Strengthen security
• Meet audit and compliance requirements
• Sleep better at night knowing they’re covered

---

Let’s Make Sure You’re Covered

Start with a free Cyber Insurance Readiness Checkup. We’ll show you:

• What’s standing between you and coverage
• What you need to fix
• How we can help you apply with confidence

Call 724-204-1950
Or request a consult at nextgen-itsolutions.com/contact

---

Final Thoughts

Cyber insurance is no longer optional—and qualifying is no longer easy.

But with the right partner, you can meet the new requirements, prove your security posture, and protect your business from devastating losses.

Let NextGEN IT Solutions help you get the coverage you need—before you really need it.